Monday, May 18, 2026
Home Blog Page 7

କାଣା କୋସଲି ମରିଜିବା ?

ଭାସା ମାନେ ମରିଜାଏସନ ବି …? ହଁ, ଆଝିର ଚଲଲା ଫିରଲା, ବେଭାର ହେଲା ଭାସା କାଲକେ ମରି ବି ଜେଇପାରେ । ହେନ୍ତା କେତନି ଭାସା ଚଲିଛନ ଆର ମରିଜେଇଛନ । ଜାତିସଂଘ ସିଖ୍ୟା, ବିଗ୍ୟାନ, ଆର ସଂସ୍କୃତି ସଂଗଠନ (UNESCO) ର ୨୦୦୩ ରେ ପ୍ରକାସିତ “ଲାଂଗୁଏଜ ଭାଇଟାଲିଟି ଏଣ୍ଡ ଏନଡେଂଜରମେନ୍ଟ” (ଭାସା ସକ୍ତି ଆର ବିପଦ ଥି) ବୁକଲେଟ ପଢଲା ଉତାରୁ ମନ ଥିର ନି ରହୁଥେଇ । କୋସଲି ଭାସା କେ ତାର ବତାଲା ନାପକାଠି ଥି ପରଖି ଦେଖୁଥିଲିଁ । ଆର କୋସଲି ଇହାଦେ ଜେନ ଥିତି ରେ ଜଉଛେ, ନିଘା କରୁଥିଲିଁ । ତାର ଆଏସ ଜହ ନୁହେ ବାଗିର ଲାଗୁଛେ । କଥାଟା ବିସ୍ୱାସ ନି ଲାଗଲେ ବି ସତ ଏ ।

ମୋର ଗୁଟେ ଆଲେଖ “ଖପେ ନି ଖପେ ବିଂଝାଲ ଭାସା” ଥି ବତେଇସାରିଛେଁ ବରଗଡ ଜିଲ୍ଲା ର ବିଂଝାଲ ଭାସା କେନ୍ତା ମରବାର ଉପରେ ଅଛେ ଆର ଆଣ୍ଡାମାନ ନିକୋବର ର ‘ବୋ’ ଭାସା ୨୦୧୦ରେ ମରିଗଲା । (https://kosalexpress.in/%e0%ac%96%e0%ac%aa%e0%ad%87-%e0%ac%a8%e0%ac%bf-%e0%ac%96%e0%ac%aa%e0%ad%87-%e0%ac%ac%e0%ac%bf%e0%ac%82%e0%ac%9d%e0%ac%be%e0%ac%b2-%e0%ac%ad%e0%ac%be%e0%ac%b8%e0%ac%be/)

ଗୁଟେ ଭାସା ଗୁଟେ ଲୋକର ସାଂସ୍କୃତିକ ବୁଦ୍ଧିର ପ୍ରତିକ ଏ । ଇହାଦେ ଦୁନିଆଁ ଥି ପ୍ରାୟ ୬୦୦୦ ଭାସା ବଁଚିଛନ । ଇହାଦେ ଦୁନିଆଁ ଥି ୯୭% ଲୋକ ଦୁନିଆଁର ମାତ୍ର ୪% ଭାସା କହେସନ ଆର ୯୬% ଭାସା ୩% ଲୋକ ବେଭାର କରସନ ।

ଗୁଟେ ଭାସା ମରସି କେନ୍ତା କରି ? ଗୁଟେ ଭାସା ସେତେବେଲେ ମରି ବସସି ଜେତେବେଲେ ସେ ଭାସି କହୁଥିବାର ଲୋକ ତାହାକେ ବେଭାର କରବାର ଛାଡିଦେସନ । ଭିନେ ଭିନେ ନୁଆଁ ଠାନେ ସେ ଭାସାର ବେଭାର ନି ହେଇପାରେ, ସେ ଭାସି ର ଲୋକମାନେ ତାକର ନୁଆଁ ପିଢି କେ ସେ ଭାସା ସିଖାବାର ଛାଡିଦେସନ । ସେତକି ବେଲକେ ଆର ଛୁଆ କି ପୁରଖା କିହେ କହେବାର କେ ନି ଥାନ । ଗୁଟେ ଗବେସଣା ନୁ ଜନା ପଡିଛେ ଏକୁସ ସଦି ର ସେସ ଆଡକେ ଦୁନିଆଁର ୯୦% ଭାସା ଆର ନି ଥାଏ ନ ।

କେନସି ବି ଭାସା ର ମରନ ଥି ଭିନେ ସାଂସ୍କୃତିକ, ଐତିହାସିକ, ପରିବେସ ବାବଦେ ଗ୍ୟାନ ର ଅପୁରା ନକସାନ ହେସି । ହରେକ ଭାସା ହଉଛେ ମାନବିକ ଅଭିଗ୍ୟଁତା ର ଅନୋଖା ପରିପ୍ରକାସନ । ଜେଭେ ବି ଗୁଟେ ଭାସା ମରିଜାଏସି ମୁନୁସର ଭାସା ର ଢାଁଚା ଆର ତାର କବାର ର ନମୁନା ବୁଝବାର ଲାଗି ଆମର ନୁ ପ୍ରମାଣ କମିଜାଏସି ମୁନୁସର ପ୍ରାକଐତିହାସିକ ଆର ଦୁନିଆଁର ବିବିଧ ପରିବେସ ତଂତ୍ର ର ଦେଖରେଖ । ଇ ସମକିରର ନୁ ଉପରେ, ସେ ଭାସି କହୁଥିବା ଲୋକମାନେ ତାକର ଭାସାର ନୁକସାନ ଥି ତାକର ମୁଲ ସଜାତିୟ ଆର ସାଂସ୍କୃତିକ ପରିଚୟ ର ନୁକସାନର ଅନୁଭବ କରିପାରବେ ।

ଜାତିସଂଘ ସିଖ୍ୟା, ବିଗ୍ୟାନ, ଆର ସଂସ୍କୃତି ସଂଗଠନ (UNESCO) ର ୨୦୦୩ ରେ ପ୍ରକାସିତ “ଲାଂଗୁଏଜ ଭାଇଟାଲିଟି ଏଣ୍ଡ ଏନଡେଂଜରମେନ୍ଟ” ଥି ୯ ଟା କାରକ ବତେଇଛେ ଆର ତାର ପାହ୍ୟ ମାନେ ଦେଇଛେ । ଭାସା କେନ କାରକ ର କେନ ପାହ୍ୟ ଥି ଅଛେ ଆର ସେ ପାହ୍ୟ ଅନସାରେ ଆପଣକର ଭାସା ର ଥିତି କାଣା । ଆସୁନ ପରଖି ଦେଖମାଁ କୋସଲି କେନ ଠାନେ ଅଛେ ।
୧)ପିଢି ନୁ ପିଢି ଭାସା ସଁପବାର – ୟୁନେସ୍କୋ ହିସାବେ କୋସଲି ପାହ୍ୟା ୪ ଥି ରହୁଛେ ଅସୁରଖିତ ବଖରା ଥି । କାଏଁଜେ କି କିଛି ଛୁଆ ସବୁ ଠାନେ ବେଭାର କରୁଥିବାର ବେଲକେ ସବୁ ଛୁଆ ମାତ୍ର କେତେଟା ଠାନେ ବେଭାର କରସନ ।
୨) ଭାସା ବେଭାର କରୁୁଥିବା ପୁରାପୁରି ସଂଖ୍ୟା – କୋସଲି କହୁଥିବା ଲୋକ ପ୍ରାୟ ୧.୮ କୋଟି ହେଲେ ବି କୋସଲି କଲେ କଲେ ଅଜାନ୍ତକେ ଉଡିଆ ଥି ମିସି ଜଉଛେ
୩)ମୋଟ ଜନସଂଖ୍ୟା ଭିତରେ ଭାସା ବେଭାର କରୁଥିବାର ଭାଗ – ପ୍ରାୟ ସବେ କହେସନ/ବେଭାର କରସନ ହେଲେ ବି ଅସୁରଖିତ (୪) ଏ ।
୪) ଖେତ୍ର ବଦଲାବାର ଥି ଭାସା ବେଭାର – ବହୁଭାସି ସମାନତା (୪), ଦୁଇ ନୁ ଅଏତକା ଭାସା ପ୍ରାୟ ସବୁ ସାମାଜିକ ଖେତ୍ର ଆର କାର୍ଜ୍ୟକ୍ରମ ଥି ବେଭାର ହେସି ।
୫) ନୁଆଁ ଖେତ୍ର ଆର ମିଡିଆକେ ପ୍ରତିକ୍ରିୟା – କୋସଲି କେତନି ନୁଆଁ ଖେତ୍ର ଥି ବେଭାର ହଉଛେ । ସେ ହିସାବେ ଗ୍ରହଣସିଲ (୩) ଥିତି ନ ଅଛେ ।
୬) ଭାସା ଥି ଗ୍ୟାନ ଆର ସିଖ୍ୟା ଦେବାର ଲାଗି ଥିବାର ସାମାନ – ଲେଖବାର ତରିକା ଲୋକକୁ ଜନା ଅଛେ, ଆର କିଛି ସାମାନ ଲେଖା ହେଇଛେ । କୋସଲି ର ଥିତି ୫ ନୁ ୧ ।
୭) ଭାସା ପ୍ରତି ସରକାରି ଆର ଅନୁସ୍ଠାନିକ ମନୋବୃତି ଆର ନିତି, ସରକାରି ଥିତି ଆର ବେଭାର କେ ମିସେଇ – କୋସଲି ଭାସା ପାହ୍ୟା ୩ ଥି ରହେବା ଜେନ ନ କି କୋସଲି କେ ତୁମ ପଡି ଉଡିଆ ଥି ମିସେଇ ଦିଆହଉଛେ ।
୮) ନିଜର ଭାସା ପ୍ରତି ଲୋକର ମନୋବୃତି – ସବେ ନିଜର ଭାସାକେ ମାଏନ ଦେସନ ଆର ଆଗକେ ଫଏଲାବାର ଚାହୁଁଛନ (୫)
୯) ଦସ୍ତାବେଜ କିସମ ଆର ଗୁଣବତା – ଠିକଠାକ (୩) । ଦରକାରି ବ୍ୟାକରଣ, ଅଭିଧାନ, କିଛି ଫି ଦିନିଆଁ ମିଡିଆ, ଅଡିଓ ଆର ଭିଡିଓ ଅଛେ ।

କୋସଲି ର ଥିତି ପରଖିଲା ଉତାରୁ ତାହାକେ ଗୁଟେ ମଜବୁତ ଭାସା ବନାବାର ଲାଗି କାଣା କରା ପଡବା:
୧) ଗୁଟେ ପିଢି ନୁ ଆର ଗୁଟେ ପିଢି କେ ଭାସା କେ ବିନା ବାଧା ରେ ଆଗକେ ବଢାବାର କେ ପଡବା ।
୨) ଛୁଆ ନୁ ବୁଢା ତକ ସମକୁ କୋସଲି ବେଭାର କରବାରକେ ପଡବା ।
୩) ଉଁଝ୍ୟା ଭାସା (ଓଡିଆ, ହିନ୍ଦି, ଇଂରାଜି ଆଦି ବିଦେସି ଭାସା) କେ ଇଲାକା ନ ଠାନ ନି ଦେଇକରି ସବୁ ଖେତ୍ର ନ କୋସଲି ଚଲାବାର କେ ପଡବା ।
୪) ନୁଆଁ ଖେତ୍ର ମାନକୁ ଜହ ନୁ ଜହ ବେଭାର କରବାର ପଡବା ।
୫) ସରକାର ଭାସା କେ ସ୍ୱିକୃତି ଦେଇକରି ଆଇନ ହିସାବେ ସୁରଖିତ ରଖବା ଆର ତାର ବିକାସ କରବା ସେଥିର ଲାଗି ଲଢେଇ ଜରୁରି ।

ସାକେତ

The Worst of Crimes Is Poverty

Dr Saheb Sahu

“The greatest evils and the worst of crimes is poverty; our first duty, a duty to which every other consideration should be sacrificed, is not to be poor.”  George Bernard Shaw, Major Barbara (1907)

Definition of Poverty

Poverty is more than just lack of income. Poor people themselves describe their experience of poverty as multidimensional-lack of money, lack of food, bad housing and sanitation, low education, poor health, social exclusion and much more. The best present definition of poverty by developmental experts is called Multidimensional Poverty Index (MPI). The MPI comprises of three dimensions-education, health and living standards. It has totalof 10 indicators -2 for education, 2 for healthcare and 6 for living standards.

 India’s national MPI index in 2021 was 25.01%, for Odisha it was 29.35% and for Kerala it was 0.71%.

Poverty in Odisha

One in every three persons in Odisha is poor; seventy five years after the Independence! Despite multiple poverty reduction schemes, welfare programs, and some cash grants by state and central government 29.35 percentof the state’s population is multi-dimensionally poor. (NITI Ayog’s National Multidimensional Poverty Index, 2021).

 Odisha is among the top-10 states with a significant share of the population living under poverty. The MPI poverty index in almost half of the districts is alarming. The MPI poverty index of district of Puri is 11.65%, the lowest in the state. But the MPI poverty index for Nabarangpur is 59.32%, Malkangiri 58.71%, Koraput 51.14%, Rayagada 48.14%, Kalahandi 44.75%, Mayurbhanj 44.9%, Kanddhamal 44.75%, and the mineral rich Kenduhar 41.78%. These are also among the 50 poorest districts in India. Only five districts have a poverty index below 20.

 According to NITI Aayog, 37.26% of the state’s population is undernourished, 19.5% has no access to maternal health and 5% of population has no access to education. Almost half of Odisha’s rural populations are poor. On the whole the coastal districts are doing relatively well, the southern and some of the districts in Western Odisha are doing badly and rest of the districts are in between.

 Addressing the 25th foundation day celebration of the BJD party, the Honorable Chief Minister of Odisha said, “Odisha will create history in bringing down the poverty rate to 10 percent. To achieve this goal, the government will take every step required” (The Hindu, Dec, 27, 2021). However, he did not specify what step or steps his government will take.

 Based on my specific interest in poverty reduction in Odisha and knowledge of developmental economics over the last 25 years, I have the following recommendations for the Honorable C.M. to reach his target of 10 percent.

1- Direct Cash Transfer

The government of Odisha should directly transfer Rs, 1000.0 to Rs, 1500.0 each month to each poor person’s bank account, or to his/her debit card or postal saving account. This will give poor women some money of their own and give them a voice in decision making at home, which is important for many other reasons. Based on Odisha’s population of 4.7 crores (2011Census) and poverty rate of 29.5%, there are 1.38crores (13.8million)people in Odisha are poor. If each of them receives an annual amount of Rs 12,000, it will cost the state about 16,525 crores rupees a year (4.78*0.295*12000= 16525). The 2021-22 budgets for the state are Rs 1, 70,000 crores.It will cost the state about 10.5% percent of 2021-22 budget (1, 70,000/16525=10.28). The money can be found by eliminating many of the less effective poverty reduction schemes (Yojanas) and persuading the central government to take part in the poverty reduction experiment. The direct cash grant will eliminate all the middle men (politicians, babus, contractors and many others) who are siphoning off certain percentage of the money at various stages of the implementation of various schemes. They are all playing the percentage game. According to multiple studies, only 10 to 15 percent of the development money reaches the poor. This is a worldwide phenomenon and not unique to Odisha.

 The direct cash grant concept is not a radical or new idea. It has been implemented in some form or other in more than 52 countries around the world including Brazil, Iran and China. The Brazilian program Bolsa –Familia reduced the poverty rate in Brazil by 28% in six years. During the last general election, the BJP government at the center was floating with the idea of the direct cash grant to the poor but did not come around to implement it. The Congress party openly advocated the plan but did not win the election to work on it.

 Developmental economists from around the world are now moving towards the concept of direct cash grant (no question asked) as a quicker and more efficient way to reduce poverty. Studies after studies have shown that poor people do not use the money to drink or gamble (as widely perceived), they spend it on food, children’s education and healthcare.  Economists Abhijit Banerjee and his wife Esther Duflo (Nobel Laureates) are in favor of the direct cash grant scheme.

2- Education

Quality public education is a core strategy in fighting poverty everywhere. Education is the key to higher wages. Girls’ education is even more important. All developmental experts agree that the potential benefits of girls’ education are many: decrease pregnancy rate, delaying marriage age, increase productivity, reduction of under-5 mortality rate, gender equality in family decision making and many more. Women who are educated are more likely to work outside the home. Women who have independent income have higher social standing and more likely to run for public office. With power comes development.

The government of Odisha should see that all children, both boys and girls attend schools and stay in schools until they finish high school. The dropout rate for girls should be drastically reduced. In rural areas there should be adequate numbers of hostels. All primary and secondary schools should have adequate infrastructures- toilets, electricity, safe drinking water and sanitation and internet connection. The schools should provide adequate nutrition and preventive healthcare.

 Students who do not want to or cannot attend college should be able to get vocational education at very low cost. The whole idea is to make them employable.

3- Facilitate Migration

 Poverty in Odisha and India is mainly a rural phenomenon. Eighty percent of people in Odisha live in villages. Odisha has 53,135 villages compare to 1670 in Kerala with close to similar population (4.7crores vs 3.5crores). Tribal people of Odisha live in inaccessible areas of the state. It is expensive and difficult to bring roads, electricity, internet, clean drinking water, good education and healthcare to rural and remote areas. There are no jobs in rural areas except some seasonal labor works. Odisha will not be able to reduce its high poverty rate unless the government makes it a policy to help rural population to migrate to small towns, cities, to other states and even to other countries where they will likely to find job. Government should also promote small scale industries in rural areas and create more jobs. No country in the world has become a developed country where majority of its population reside in the rural areas. China’s population like that of India in 1970s was predominately rural. Now only 38 percent of the population in China lives in rural areas compare to 65% in India. In the Unites States, it is 19 percent.

 Out of the total population of 3.4 crores, 40 Lakhs Keralites are working outside India and 14 lakhs are working in other Indian states, a total of 54 lakhs. Odisha has a population of 4.7 crores but only about 15 lakhs Oriyas are working outside the state and most of them as seasonal migrant workers. A farmer in Odisha makes about Rs 6000 to Rs 7000 a month. A migrant worker from Odisha working in brick factory makes around RS 10,000 to RS 20,000 a month. Instead of denying that large scale migration is happening, Odisha government should do everything in its power to help people migrate from the state for better job opportunities outside. Educated Oriyas in large number have already migrated to Delhi, Bengaluru, Hyderabad, Chennai and Pune. Migration is good for the workers and their families. In towns and cities their children get a better education and more employment opportunitiesand move out of poverty.

Conclusion

Odisha is making progress in poverty reduction but the pace is slow 1% to 1.5% a year.  There is no easy or quick solution to poverty eradication. However, education and migration are two of the oldest actions against poverty. People, who get an education, usually get a better paying job and move their family out of poverty. Government of Odisha should see that all children attend school and stay in school until they finish high school. Make college education accessible and affordable. Provide low cost or no cost vocational education to those who cannot attend college. With proper education, Oriyas can get a job within or outside the state.

Poor people who are desperate enough or bold enough to leave their villages and move to a nearby town or city, escape the grinding poverty of their village. Late Harvard economist professor John Galbraith observed decades ago, “There is nothing great about blue sky and clean air when you are starving”.

 In 1940s and 1950s people from coastal Odisha migrated to Calcutta and from Western and Northern Odisha migrated to Jamshedpur.Large number of poor Oriyas especially from Western and Southern Odisha are now migrating to other states for seasonal works. Instead of denying that large scale migration is happening, Odisha government should facilitate their migration. Odisha should follow the example of Kerala on education and migration policies.

If the Honorable CM of Odisha wants to achieve his goal of reducing the poverty rate of Odisha to 10 percent in next five years he has only one choice. He should direct his government to transfer Rs1, 000 to Rs 1,500 per month to each poor Oriya’s bank accountor postal account or debit card.  It will cost about 10 percent of the state budget per year for next few years and will bring down the poverty rate to below ten percent.

Honorable CM, you have lot of political capital. Please use it. People of Odisha trust you. Take a bold step and implement the program of direct cash grant to all the poor people of Odisha without any delay. You will get some push back from other politicians, bureaucrats and other vested interest groups, please ignore them. You will achieve your target of reducing the poverty rate of Odisha to 10% in five years. This will be your lasting legacy!

PS: Dr Saheb Sahu is a son of small scale farmer parents, who grew up in a village in Bargarh district, Odisha. He is a graduate of AIIMS (New Delhi), settled in USA. He is a former Managing Director of Kalinga Hospital (BBSR) and an expert member of Western Odisha Development Council. He has published few articles, one booklet and one book on Odisha’s Poverty.

Rebuttal to Dr Debiprasanna’s Outburst against Koshali

When I learnt that Odia got classical status, I was glad. Within two weeks of this announcement learnt that Koshali has been recommended by Odisha government to be included in the eigth schedule, I was elated. Koshalis have been asking for their language to be recognised for very practical purposes for a long time. I remember my early childhood days when for umpteenth number of times I had to stand on my stool because I spoke Koshali in my class. Koshali students always were disadvantaged compared to kids from coastal area in both written and verbal expression of school subjects even though their knowledge of matter was not any worse. I know of many of my classmates failing again and again in Odia though their marks in other subjects was okay, and became dropouts.

Non-recognition of Koshali has other important consequences. Interestingly, it has influenced the migratory pattern within Odisha. You will find numerous migrants from coastal Odisha in teaching, clerical and other lower level civil service in all parts of Koshal but you won’t find migration in the same scale from Koshal to coastal Odisha. Kosholis are moving west to Chhattisgagh and Madhya Pradesh.Non-recognition of Koshali has made Koshalis feel alien in their own land. Therefore I am so happy that this major irritant is about to be removed. In my humble opinion,the social impact of recognition of Koshali is far more profound than recognition of Odia as a classical language.

The other benefits will also accrue. Koshali is as rich and sweet as Awadhi, which is the language of Tulsidas Ramayana. Koshal’s poetic genius, such as GangadharMeher and Bhimabhoi have embellished Odia literature over the last century.Now I see the renaissance which has started in enrichment of Koshali literature with little or no government support for the last fifty year or so will get be further encouragement. A new generation of Koshali poets, playwrights, storytellers, film-makers, artists and creative folks are pouring in their creations. It is as if the dammed up creativity has been unleashed. This will lead to de facto recognition of Odisha as a state with two major languages in addition to many smaller tribal languages. One of my students, Dr.AjitMohanty recently wrote that experiments in teaching some tribal kids in their own language have been found very successful in Odisha. This confirms my conviction that mother tongue is the most efficient mode for teaching young kids. Therefore Odisha government must be congratulated for this step which should have been taken long time ago. This is why I was shocked to see the comments of Dr. DebiP Patnaik in The Telegraph, where he says,

“On February 20, I was delighted to learn that the Union Cabinet had given its nod to grant classical tag to Odia.Nine days later I was suffered immense pain when I came to know that our chief minister Naveen Patnaik had written a letter to the Centre for including languages such as Sambalpuri/ Koshali and Ho in the Eighth Schedule of the Indian Constitution.”

Though I have great respect for Dr.Patnaik as one academic to another and for the way he stick- handled the acceptance of Odia as a classical language, I find such outburst as irresponsible, unwise and incendiary. It is reminiscent of “Odiaswatantrabhashanoi” slogan of Kantilal Bhattacharya in 1870 when Odia speakers were trying to proclaim Odia as a separate language in its own right, not an apabhransha of Bengali.I do not understand what makes him so hostile towards Koshalis ? What harm have we caused to him or Odisha ? Why does he want to perpetuate an unvarnished colonial attitude towards Koshal ? What could have been a win win situation, he made it into lose-lose situation because he just ignited the perennial conflict between Koshalis and coastal Odishans. Does he want to recreate a pan-Odia empire (it was called Kalingan empire in his submission for classical status of Odia)from Ganga to Godavari erasing all the cultural and linguistic heritages of all people within his field of dream ?. Really !! Dr.Patnaik has become an nineteenth century pan-Bengalinationalist(such as Dr. Rajendralal Mitra and Kantilal Bhattacharya) this time in Odia garb.

It seems Dr. Patnaik does not like the idea of recognising any language in the eighth schedule,. If so he should take his fight with the central government which has got this frame work, not Odisha government, which is following the guide line in place.

More recently four more languages have been included in the 8th schedule. Ironically, according to one of his recent essays, he was an advisor to the Bodo group whose language was recognised under 8th schedule as to script they should use.For his effort, he got his Padmashree. What is so special about Bodo,Santhali,Maithili andDongri; what they have which Koshali does not ? Why is it alright to enjoy a warm feeling of worth because Odia got classical status and is so painful to bear the thought that Koshali might be included in the eighth schedule? If Dr.Patnaik thinks that by raising objection to Odisha government’s endorsement to Koshali,he can somehow derail the process of inclusion in the 8th schedule, he better think of the consequence. Recently our survey indicates that all leaders irrespective of all political affiliations are completely committed to the cause of Koshali language just asstrongly the general population is. This is not a negotiable subject matter anymore. Any tempering with the process will result in consequences which will have profound effect on the very integrity of the state.

There is genuine fear among the coastal intelligentsia that recognition of Koshali will eventually lead to separation. For fear of separation, coastal intelligentsia objected when, Sambalpur and Berhampur universities were created, when Burla Engineering college was established in Burla and when Regional Engineering college was established in Rourkela. History proves this thesis to be wrong; if anything these attempts softened the demand for separation. Debi Babu’s solution is to strengthen Odia language and that will prevent any sentiment of separation. He has been demanding five hundred crores from the government to create an Odia university, where ALL subjects would be taught in Odia right upto post-graduate level. In addition seven or so other Indian languages would be taught.

If anybody has bothered to look at the condition of state universities in Odisha, he will find that more than half of the academic positions are vacant because state government cannot afford to pay the salary of these profs. Some of the hardest hit are Odia departments because graduates cannot find any employment after graduation. In the mean time state government is announcing creation of more universities and medical colleges. So acceding to Debi Babu’s proposal, which is a colourful dream of a linguist, may end up being very costly without much of tangible benefits! But the idea that language alone will hold a state together is passé. It did not prevent formation of Telengana. It did not prevent formation of Chhattisgarh or Uttarakhand either. If Mayavati will have her way, U.P. would be split into four provinces! What binds the population together are good governance, a sense in the population that that the state government provides equal access to all the resources of the state irrespective of location or cultural/linguistic or religious affiliation, a sense of fair play when it comes dealing with grivances and an ambiance of good relationship between government and governed, among others.

Ever since the inception of the state, intelligentsia and bureaucrats from coastal Odisha have been suppressing the development of Koshal area sometimes bluntly and often surreptitiously with excuses that such development will stimulate separatist feelings. Objections, similar to the one Debi Babu just raised, had been raised, when Sambalpur university was established, when BurlaEngineering college was established in Burla, when Regional Engineering college was established in Rourkela, and when a Diploma course in Koshali was instituted in Sambalpur University.

During the five years or so, Odishans from all quarters of the state campaigned for central educational institutions at the tertiary levels showing that Odisha has been neglected. Central government agreed and tried to correct the situation and granted IIT, NISER, AIIMS, Central Univerity of Law, Post Graduate University of Public Health, EISC medical college and a central University. Not a single one of these institutions were established in Koshal area. Koshal has become the heartland of industrialisation, but there has not been matching growth in human resource development. All these institutions, except the central university went to the sixty mile zone coastal area.

Recently, entire Koshal area agitated in unison to have a branch of High Court so that Koshalis can a little better access to jurisprudence. What seems to be good for the province was actively opposed by the lawyers of High Court in Cuttack, by having a strike !How dare the Koshalis even think that they would have access to legal remedy in a High Court without going through Cuttack, they argued. All such manuevres are perpetrated against Koshalis because apparently if Koshalis become better educated and have easier access to services, they may want a separate state. So I am not surprised by Debi Babu’s outburst against Koshalis. This is one of many indignities we have learnt to endure, but remarks contained in his comments are below the belt, and crosses the line. Such overt attack is not banter due to sibling rivalry but sounds like fratricidal battle cry. Debi Babu wants Koshalis to remain as second class citizen forever. So ever wonder, why Koshalis want a separate state?

Dr Arjun Purohit

(Canada)

What Women Want ?

0

Dr Saheb Sahu

Once in the mythical city of Bagdad, a thief was brought in front of the caliph to be judged. The usual punishment was  to have his hands cut off, but that day the caliph was in a good mood and he offered the bandit a way out. “Tell me what women want and you will be free,” he said. The man thought for a while, and after invoking Allah and His Prophet, he gave the caliph an astute answer. “Oh, sublime caliph, women want to be heard. Ask them what they want and they will tell you.”

 This is what women want: to be educated, to have their own resources, to be safe, to have control over their bodies and lives, and above all, to be treated as equal. (Allende)

I will confine my discussion to women in India.

A – To Be Educated

Though it is sharply increasing, the female literacy rate in India is less than the male literacy rate. Far fewer girls than boys are enrolled in school, and many girls drop out. In urban India, girls are nearly on a par with boys in terms of education. However, in rural India, girls continue to be less educated than boys.

According to National Family Health Survey (NFHS) 2019-21, the average literacy rate in India was 77.7%, 84.7% for male and 70.3% for female. The highest literacy rate was in Kerala. The average was 96.2%, and for male 97.4% and for female 95.2% .In Odisha the average was 77.3%, and for male 84.0% and for female 70.3%.

 According to experts no country has attained developed status without educating most of its population. Quality public education is core strategy in fighting poverty everywhere. Not only education is important in fighting poverty, it is also key to wealth creation. Without creating wealth poverty cannot be eradicated.

 All developmental experts agree that the potential benefits of girls’ education are even greater than that of boys’ education. The benefits of educating girls are many: decrease pregnancy rate, reduction of under- 5 mortality rates, increase productivity and income, gender equality in family decision making and many more. Women who are educated are more likely to work outside the home. Women who have independent income have higher social standing and more likely to run for political office.

B – To Have Resources of Their Own

How does one get resources of one’s own? One gets an education and gets a job or inherits some wealth. If you do not have a decent education, your chance of getting a job in India is very slim. Without an education a woman will be a laborer or domestic servant. In India women have equal rights under law to own property and receive equal share of their inheritance like their brothers, but in practice, it is not happening.

Women constitute almost half of Indian population (48%), but their participation in the work force amounts only to one-fourth of the total working people. The gender pay gap in India is estimated to be around 20 % (2019), e.g. women make 80 cents while make a rupee for similar work.

 Women perform around 10 times more unpaid works (house hold work, caring for children and parents) than men do. Sixty percent of working women in India work in agriculture sectors, where the pay is low. Research suggests that when countries are able to raise the female labor participation rate, this stands to benefit the entire economy.

 Only about four percent CEOs of Indian major companies are women. In Indian Lok Sabha out of 543 members only 78 are women (14%).

C- To Be Safe

 Violence against women has been common in most societies for millennia. It is worse in India. A young woman thinks twice before doing something as routine as walking past a group of men. Safety of women in India is threatened by various acts like- feticide (aborting female fetuses), child marriage, domestic violence, rape, forced prostitution, honor killing, bride burning for dowry, sexual harassment at work place and many more. About third of Indian women have suffered from domestic violence.

 Nearly a decade since the gang rape and murder of a student on a bus in Delhi that shocked the country, state and central spending to combat violence against women is “grossly inadequate”, according to Oxfam India.

 How to solve this unacceptable situation? All the state governments should vigorously enforce the existing laws against all forms of violence against girls and women. Child labor should be completely banned. All girls until the age of 16 should attend schools. Some of the reasons for drooping out of schools are under-age marriage, pregnancy and child labor. Sanitary pads, birth control pills, morning after pills, immunizations,  iron and vitamin tablets should be available to all high-school and college- going  girls at low cost  or be free.

Families, educational institutions, and societies should teach boys and men to respect women. Only strict laws on the books will not solve the problem of women safety in India. Implementation of existing laws in a time bound manner will help. However, unless men change their mindset towards women, laws alone will not solve the problem. Unfortunately politicians are satisfied with passing the laws but are not serious enough to implement them in a timely manner.

D- To Be Treated As Equal

Although the constitution of India grants men and women equal rights, gender disparities remain in all aspects of Indian lives.  While Indian laws on domestic violence, rape, and dowry related killing, and adultery have women’s safety at heart, these unacceptable crimes are still rampant in India.

 Women have equal inheritance rights under the law, but in real practice, they are not inheriting equal shares of their parental properties as their brothers. Less than 25% of women own any agricultural land in their names.

 India is one of the largest and fastest growing economies in the world. Yet, when it comes to gender equality, India ranks poorly on global indicators (UNICEF). Across India gender inequality results in unequal opportunities for girls and women, almost in all spheres of their lives.

 The root cause of gender inequality in Indian society lies in its patriarchy system going back to thousands of years. Patriarchy is defined as a system of social structure and practices, in which men dominate, oppress and exploit women. Exploitation of women is a cultural phenomenon of Indian society. The system of patriarchy finds its validity and sanctions in India’s religious beliefs, whether it is Hindu, Muslim or any other religion.

 For instance, as per Ancient Hindu law giver Manu,” Women are supposed to be in the custody of their fathers when they are children, must be under the custody of their husbands when married and under the custody of their son in old age or as widows.”

 Most girls and women in India do not fully enjoy many of their rights due to deeply entrenched patriarchal views, norms, traditions and social structure.  The patriarchal system is changing but not fast enough. India will not be a developed country unless both girls and boys are equally supported to reach their full potential.

Conclusion

The UN Commission on the Status of Women adopted agreed conclusions on “Women’s full and effective participation and decision-making in public life, as well as the elimination of violence, for achieving gender equality and the empowerment of all women and girls” on 26 March 2021.

Women all over the world want to be educated, have their own resources, to be safe and like to be treated equal to men. Unfortunately, in most countries these aspirations are not being met. India is no exception. According to UNICEF, when it comes to gender equality, India ranks poorly on various indicators. India’s constitution guarantees equal rights to women with men but in real life, every day, in every part of India; women are treated as second class citizens. Things are changing but in a snail pace. The age-old patriarchy system persists. Unless women get an education, are employed in large number outside their homes, have their own money and resources, and get political power, things are not going to change that much. In 2014, 11.42% members of Lok Sabha were women. It increased to 14.36% in 2019. What a slow progress! Unless Indian women are elected to all political offices (from panchayat to parliament) in much larger percentage than at present, things will not change fast.

Sources

1- Isabella Allende. The Soul of A Woman. Ballantine Books: New York, 2020

2-UN Women.org

Culture, Religion and Science: Dr Saheb Sahu

0

Culture

Definition of Culture

Culture is an umbrella term which encompasses the social behavior and norms found in human societies, as well the knowledge, beliefs, arts, laws, customs, capabilities, and habits of the individuals in these groups. Humans acquire culture through learning process of enculturation (the process by which an individual learns the traditional content of a culture and assimilates its practices and values.) and socialization, which is shown by the diversity of culture across societies. These include expressive forms like art, music, dance, ritual, religion, and technologies like tool usage, cooking, shelter, and clothing.

 Most people tend to believe that they are the center of the world, and their culture is the anchor of the human history. Chinese nationalists believe that history really began with the Yellow Emperor and Xia and Shang dynasties, and that whatever Westerners, Muslims, or Indians achieved is but a pale copy of original Chinese ideas and inventions.

 Indian nativists dismiss these Chinese boasts and argued that even airplanes and nuclear bombs were invented by ancient Indian sages. They believe that Maharishi Bhardwaj invented rockets and airplanes, Viswamitra not only invented but also used missiles and Acharya Kanad was the father of atomic theory.

 Many Greeks believe that history began with Homer, Sophocles, and Plato and that all important ideas and inventions were born in Athens, Sparta, Alexandria, or Constantinople.

 Pious Muslims regard all history prior to Prophet Muhammad as largely irrelevant, and they consider all history after the revelation of Quran to revolve around the Muslim umma. The main exceptions are the Turkish, Iranian, and Egyptian nationalists, who argue that even prior to Muhammad their particular nation was the fountainhead of all that was good about humanity.

 Needless to say, the British, French, Germans, Italians, Russians, Japanese, Americans, and countless other groups are similarly convinced that their cultures, their political systems and religious practices were essential to the very laws of physics.

All these claims are false. They combine a wishful ignorance of history with more than a hint of racism. None of the nations or religions of today existed when humans colonized the world, domesticated plants and animals, built the first cities, or invented writing and money. Morality, art, spirituality and creativity are universal human abilities embedded in our DNA. Their beginning (based on our present knowledge) was in Stone Age Africa. It is therefore crass egotism to ascribe to them a more recent place and time, be it China, India, Greece or Arabia in the age of Muhammad. (Harari)

Religion

Definition of Religion

The definition of religion is a controversial and complicated subject in religious studies, with scholars failing to agree on any one definition. Oxford Dictionaries defines religion as the belief in and/or worship of a superhuman controlling power, especially a personal God or gods.

 According to many scholars religion is a modern Western concept. Parallel concepts are not found in many current and past cultures. There is no equivalent term for religion in many languages. An increasing number of scholars have expressed reservation about ever defining the essence of religion. (Wikipedia)

There are over 4,000 religions in the world, but three –quarters of the world’s population practice one of the five major religions: Christianity, Islam, Hinduism, Buddhism and Shinto.

Westerners often use the term “the three great religions”: Christianity (2.3billion adherents), Islam (1.9 billion), and Judaism (15 million). Hinduism, with its 1.2 billion believers, and Buddhism, with its 500 million followers- not to mention the Shinto religion (87 million) and the Sikh (26 million) do not make the cut. Followers of the ‘three great religions” believe that all major religious traditions emerged out of the womb of Judaism, which was the first religion to preach universal ethical rules like the Ten Commandments. But this is a baseless and insolvent idea, which ignores the world’s most important ethical traditions.

 Stone Age hunter-gather tribes had moral codes tens of thousands years before Judaism. When the first European settlers reached Australia in the late eighteenth century, they encountered Aboriginal tribes that had a well-developed ethical worldview despite being totally ignorant of Moses, Jesus, and Muhammad.

 Scientists nowadays point out that morality in fact has deep evolutionary roots. All social mammals, such as wolves, dolphins and monkeys, have ethical codes, adapted by evolution to promote group cooperation. For example, when wolf pups play with one another, they have “fair game” rules. If a pup bites too hard or continues to bite an opponent, the other pup will stop playing with him.  In chimpanzee bands dominant members are expected to respect the property rights of weaker members. If a junior female chimpanzee finds a banana, even the alpha male will usually avoid stealing it for himself.

 The so called biblical prophecies of “Thou shalt not kill” and “Thou shalt not steal” were well known in the legal and ethical codes of Sumerian city-states, pharaonic Egypt and the Babylonian Empire.

 The Bible is far from being the exclusive source of human morality. Confucius, Laozi, Buddha, and Mahavira established universal ethical codes long before Jesus. And at a time when Judaism still mandated the sacrifice of animals, Mahavira and Buddha were already instructing their followers to avoid harming not only all human beings but any living being whatsoever, even including insects. It therefore makes no sense to credit Judaism, Christianity and Islam for creation of human morality.

The Birth of Bigotry

Bigotry is defined as obstinate or intolerant devotion to one’s own opinions and prejudices. Followers of monotheistic religions (Judaism, Christianity and Islam) believe in a single God. The first concept of a single God goes back to Pharaoh Akhenaten of Egypt, around 1350 BCE, long before the God of the Old Testament, Yahweh. Followers of monotheistic religions believe that there are no other Gods except their own, called Yahweh, Jesus or Allah. Polytheists like the Hindus find it perfectly acceptable that different people worship different gods. They rarely if ever fought, persecuted, or killed people just because of their religious beliefs. The big exception was the 1947 partition of India and Pakistan. Monotheists, in contrast, believed that their God was the only god, and that he demanded universal obedience. Consequently, as Christianity and Islam spread around the world, so did the incidence of crusades, jihads, inquisitions, and religious discrimination. Even the Jews, the fellow monotheists were not spared. The Jews have been persecuted by the Christians from the 4th century onward culminating in the death of round 6 million Jews by Nazi Germany during the Holocaust (1941-1945).

By insisting that “there is no god but our God,” monotheistic idea tends to encourage bigotry according to Yuval Harari, lecturer at Hebrew University of Jerusalem. He says, “Do you really think Muslims or Christians or Jews are more ethical than Hindus just because they believe in many gods?”

Science

Science is the pursuit and application of knowledge and understanding of the natural and social world following a systematic methodology based on evidence.

Scientific methodology includes the following:

  • Objective observation: Measurement and data (possibly although not necessarily using mathematics as a tool)
  • Evidence
  • Experiment and/or observation as benchmarks for testing hypotheses
  • Induction: reasoning to establish general rules or conclusions drawn from facts or examples
  • Repetition
  • Critical analysis
  • Verification and testing: critical exposure to scrutiny, peer review and assessment

Modern science is typically divided into three major branches[ that consist of the natural sciences (e.g., biologychemistry, and physics), which study nature in the broadest sense; the social sciences (e.g., economicspsychology, and sociology), which study individuals and societies. Disciplines that use existing scientific knowledge for practical purposes, such as engineering and medicine, are described as applied sciences.

What is the difference between science and religion?

  • Science tends to concern itself with the natural or physical world – that which can be observed and measured. If it cannot be observed or measured empirically, then it is not scientific.
  • Scientific knowledge is gained primarily through the experimental method: a hypothesis is formulated and then experiments designed to test the hypothesis. Experiments use standardized procedures of data collection, so that other scientists can repeat the exact same experiment in the same way and verify the data and test the findings for them.
  • In contrast religion tends to concern itself with the spiritual world, many aspects of which cannot necessarily be observed and measured in a scientific extent. For example, knowledge in many religions comes ultimately from God, and belief in the existence of God cannot be verified empirically. Belief in God is a matter of faith.
  • Any knowledge claims made by religions which are not verifiable by empirical observations cannot be regarded as ‘scientific’.

Conclusion

Culture is much   older than religion and religion is older than science. Humans acquire culture through learning process of enculturation and socialization, which is shown by the diversity of culture across societies. These include art, music, dance, food, shelter and clothing. Each society has its own culture which it has acquired over long time. The idea that Western culture is better than other culture is product of ignorance and racial bias by the Westerners.

 It is certainly true that belief in god was vital to various social orders, and that it sometimes had positive consequences. Indeed, the very same religions that inspire hate and bigotry in some followers inspire love and compassion in others. Yet even though belief in gods can inspire us to act compassionately, religious faith is not necessary condition for moral behavior. Morality of some kind is natural. All social animals from chimpanzees to rats have ethical codes that limit behavior like theft and murder. Among humans, morality is present in all societies, even though not all of them believe in the same god, or in any god. We don’t need to invoke God’s name in order to live a moral life. Secularism can provide us with all the values we need.

What then is the secular idea? The most important secular commitment is to the truth, which is based on observation and evidence rather than on mere faith. Secularists strive not to confuse truth with belief. In addition, secularists do not sanctify any group, person, or book as if it and it alone has sole custody of the truth. This commitment to the truth underlies modern science, which has enabled humankind to crack the atom, track the evolution of life from one cell organism to a highly evolved human being, cured many diseases and sent men to the moon.

I will conclude this essay with a quote from late Stephen Hawking, Professor of Physics and Cosmology at Cambridge University.

“There is a fundamental difference between religion, which is based on authority, and science which is based on observation and reason. Science will win because it works”.

Sources

  1. Yuval Noah Harari, 21 Lessons for the 21st Century. New York: Spiegel& Grau, 2018
  2.  Wikipedia.org, Feb, 15, 22.

CLEAR urges governments to follow policies of mother tongue based education and language equality to make India a powerful knowledge economy

0


Campaign for Language Equality and Rights (CLEAR) greets all citizens of India on this great  International Mother Language Day, celebrated across the world.
On this day, we would like to urgent both the Union and State governments in India to uphold the flags of our mother languages and guarantee the language rights to all of us without any discrimination whatsoever.
In every state in India, in the name of education, the mother language medium education is attacked by market forces and clueless governments. Millions of students, particularly in rural India, won’t be educated in English alone. Though we don’t reduce the importance of English or any other language considered useful, it is very clear that mother tongue-based education is the foundation to set the stage of our children for further learning of any language or subjects. 
Every country that achieved great advancements in becoming a knowledge economy, did so with the help of widespread and modern education to the people in their languages. By making languages as the carriers of knowledge, societies achieve a strong foundation in creating millions of youths as knowledge workers.  Having a few elite schools here and there, forcing English, or renouncing mother tongues won’t help. 
On the Union government level, the discrimination of languages prevail despite the strong protests across India by various language people. For example, every union government program’s name is either in Sanskrit or Hindi. The names aren’t got translated for different states. Many union ministers still send their letters to the non-Hindi states in Hindi alone, despite the protests by the members of parliament and ruling by courts. The official language rules have clearly told us that non-Hindi states to be communicated not in Hindi. 
In every state, the discriminatory language politics of India has played havoc with the lives of the native people.  
This year, in Kerala, the language rights activists fought for proper implementation of Malayalam education in CBSE schools and engineering colleges In West Bengal, language activists went to the court to direct banks to support Bengali in the banks in Bangladesh. In Tamil Nadu, and even ask the state government to protect the world famous Bengali film industry. In Tamil Nadu, the finance minister Mr Palanivel Thiyagarajan asked the banks to implement native language support in all of its public services. In Karnataka, Maharashtra, Punjab, Odisha and many other states, language activists continue to protest for language rights.and mother tongue education.
CLEAR urges both the union and state governments to upload the rights of all languages in India and understand no imperial language policy would help the country to become a knowledge economy. The only route to become a global knowledge powerhouse goes through the mother tongue education and the only way to guarantee the unity and integrity of the great country is through treating all languages equal. 

Thanks and regards

Dr Joga Singh Virk, President
Mr Aazhi Senthilnathan, Federal Secretary

Ten Precepts for Everyday Life

0

 Dr Saheb Sahu

1- The Golden Rule

The Golden Rule is the principle of treating others as one wants to be treated. It is a maxim that is found in most religions and cultures. . It can be considered an ethic of reciprocity in some religions, although different religions treat it differently.

The maxim may appear as a positive or negative injunction governing conduct:

  • Treat others as you would like others to treat you (positive or directive form)
  • Do not treat others in ways that you would not like to be treated (negative or prohibitive form)
  • What you wish upon others, you wish upon yourself (empathetic or responsive form)

The idea dates at least to the early Confucian times (551–479 BCE). The concept appears prominently in Buddhism, Hinduism, Judaism, Christianity and Islam.

2- In-group/Out-group (Us vs them)

An in-group is a group of people who identify with each other based on a variety of factors including gender, race, religion, or geography. Our tendency to distinguish between in-group and out-group members has moral implications.

People may harm those whom they perceive to be in an out-group in ways that they would not harm in-group members. For example, one study showed that when soccer fans viewed fans of their own team being harmed, they felt empathy. But when they viewed fans of a rival team being similarly harmed, they felt pleasure.

Likewise, people tend to make different moral judgments based on in-group and out-group distinctions. When someone in our in-group misbehaves, the natural reaction is often to dismiss the behavior as no big deal. But when someone in our out-group does the same thing, we will tend to judge the behavior much more harshly.

Indeed, when automatic in-group and out-group distinctions replace conscious and thoughtful reflection, we are more likely to harm one another and behave unethically.

3-Cognitive Biases

A cognitive bias is a systematic pattern of deviation from norm or rationality in judgment. A continually evolving list of cognitive biases has been identified over the last six decades of research on human judgment and decision-making in cognitive science, social psychology, and behavioral economics. Daniel Kahneman and Tversky (1996) argue that cognitive biases have efficient practical implications for areas including clinical judgment, entrepreneurship, finance, and management.

Here is a list of commonly debated biases in judgment and decision-making:

  • Selective search for evidence (also known as confirmation bias): People tend to be willing to gather facts that support certain conclusions but disregard other facts that support different conclusions.
  • Cognitive inertia is the unwillingness to change existing thought patterns in the face of new circumstances.
  • Wishful thinking is a tendency to want to see things in a certain – usually positive – light, which can distort perception and thinking.
  • Recency: People tend to place more attention on more recent information and either ignore or forget more distant information.
  • Repetition bias is a willingness to believe what one has been told most often and by the greatest number of different sources.
  • Anchoring and adjustment: Decisions are unduly influenced by initial information that shapes our view of subsequent information.
  • Group think is peer pressure to conform to the opinions held by the group.

People tend to attribute their own success to internal factors, including abilities and talents, but explain their failures in terms of external factors such as bad luck. The reverse bias is shown when people explain others’ success or failure.

And underestimating uncertainty the illusion of control: People tend to underestimate future uncertainty because of a tendency to believe they have more control over events than they really do.

Prospect theory involves the idea that when faced with a decision-making event, an individual is more likely to take on a risk when evaluating potential losses, and are more likely to avoid risks when evaluating potential gains.

Optimism bias is a tendency to overestimate the likelihood of positive events occurring in the future and underestimate the likelihood of negative life events. An optimism bias can alter risk perception and decision-making in many domains, ranging from finance to health.

4-There Aren’t No Such Thing as a Free Lunch (TANSTAAFL)

“There aren’t any such things as a free lunch” (TANSTAAFL), also known as “there is no such thing as a free lunch” (TINSTAAFL), is an expression that describes the cost of decision-making and consumption. The expression conveys the idea that things appearing free always have some cost paid by somebody, or that nothing in life is truly free.

A free lunch refers to a situation where there is no cost incurred by the individual receiving the goods or services being provided, but economists point out that even if something were truly free there is an opportunity cost in what is not taken.

How TANSTAAFL Works

The TANSTAAFL concept is important to consider when making various types of decisions, whether they be financial or lifestyle. The concept can help consumers make wiser decisions by considering all indirect and direct costs and externalities.

 Decision-making requires trade-offs and assumes that there are no real free offerings in society. For example, products and services gifted (free) to individuals are not truly free; a company, government, or individual ultimately pays the cost.

Investors must remain particularly wary of a seemingly free lunch when dealing with investments that promise a stream of fairly high, fixed payments over a period of multiple years with supposedly low risk. Many of these investments remain laden with hidden fees, some of which may not be fully understood by investors. In general, any investment that promises a guaranteed return is not a free lunch because there is some implicit cost somewhere, including the opportunity cost of not investing elsewhere.

5- Pareto Principle or 80-20 Rule

The Pareto principle states that for many outcomes, roughly 80% of consequences come from 20% of causes (the “vital few”). Other names for this principle are the 80/20 rule, the law of the vital few.

Management consultant Joseph M. Juan developed the concept in the context of quality control, and improvement, naming it after Italian economist Vilfredo Pareto, who noted the 80/20 connection in 1896. In his first work, Cours d’économie politique, Pareto showed that approximately 80% of the land in Italy was owned by 20% of the population.

So Why Is This Useful?

The Pareto Principle is not a mathematical formula but it helps you realize that the majority of results come from a minority of inputs. Knowing this, if…

.20% of workers contribute 80% of results: Focus on rewarding these employees.

.20% of customers contribute 80% of revenue: Focus on satisfying these customers.

The examples go on. Prioritize your daily activities. Try to finish the 20 percent of the important tasks of the day.

6- Good Judgment vs Bad Judgment

Good judgement comes from experience. Experience often comes from bad judgement. – Mulla Nasrudin

To succeed in life you need many qualities, but underlying them all is good judgment. Those with ambition but no judgment run out of money. Those with passion but no judgment hurl themselves down the wrong paths. Those with drive but no judgment get up very early to do the wrong things. Sheer luck and factors beyond your control may determine your eventual success, but good judgment will stack the cards in your favor.

 Some elements to arrive at good judgments are:

  • Learning: Listen Attentively, Read Critically
  • Seek diversity of opinion and not validation
  • Detachment: Identify, and then challenge various biases
  • Options: Question the set of solutions offered,
  • Factor in the feasibility of execution
  • .Success is Not a Reliable Proxy for Judgment

7- Black Swan theory

Black swans are native to Australia and European did not see a black swan until the 17th century and believed that they do not exist.

The black swan theory or theory of black swan events is a metaphor that describes an event that comes as a surprise, has a major effect, and is often inappropriately rationalized after the fact with the benefit of hindsight… The term was popularized by Nassim Nicholas Taleb, a finance professor, writer and former Wall Street trader,  

In his 2001 Book Fooled by Randomness, this concerned financial events. His 2007 book The Black Swan extended the metaphor to events outside of financial markets.Taleb regards almost all major scientific discoveries, historical events, and artistic accomplishments as “black swans”—undirected and unpredicted. He gives the rise of the Internet, the personal computerWorld War I, the dissolution of the Soviet Union, and the September 11, 2001 attacks as examples of black swan events.

Taleb states that a black swan event depends on the observer. For example, what may be a black swan surprise for a turkey is not a black swan surprise to its butcher; hence the objective should be to “avoid being the turkey” by identifying areas of vulnerability in order to “turn the Black Swans white”.

8. Saving and Investing

The way to financial stability is simple. Live within your means by reducing your expenses well below your income. Maximize your employer’s retirement benefits. Save at least 10 percent of your income every month by auto deduction so that you don’t see the money.

The power of compounding

For example-if someone who starts investing $5,000 per year at age 25 winds up with $1.3 million by age 65, while someone who waits until age 35 to start investing $5,000 per year(until the age of 65),winds up with just $566,000 at age 65(assuming annual rate of return of 8%).

The Rule of 72

To use the rule is to divide any percentage return into 72 to find how long it takes to double your money. Example: At 8 percent return, how long does it take to double your money? Easy: nine years (72 divided by 8=9). If the return is 3 percent, it will take 24 years (72 divided by 3=24).

Invest in Index Funds

What is an index fund and how does it work?

An “index fund” is a type of mutual fund or exchange-traded fund that seeks to track the returns of a market index like Nifty Fifty Index. Index funds are very low cost and eliminate the anxiety and expense of trying to predict which individual stocks, bonds, or mutual funds will beat the market.

For Indian context you can invest in Nifty fifty Index funds or similar index funds traded in Mumbai stock exchange.  The annual return for Nifty fifty index funds in India has been between 17- 18 percent over the last five years.

ETF- You may also want to consider exchange –traded index funds or ETFS. These are index funds that trade on the major stock exchanges and can be bought and sold like stocks.

9- “Health Is Wealth”

“Health is Wealth” is a very old proverb.  It puts health before wealth. A healthy person can earn wealth anytime.  There can be no wealth without health.

Achieving and maintaining health is an ongoing process. It takes works to stay healthy.

Diet

A healthy eating plan: Emphasizes vegetables, fruits, whole grains, and fat-free or low-fat dairy products .It includes lean meats, poultry, fish, beans, eggs, and nuts and limitssaturated and Trans fats (processed foods), sodium, and added sugars.

Exercise

Physical exercise enhances or maintains physical fitness and overall health and wellness. It strengthens one’s bones and muscles and improves the cardiovascular and brain health. There are four types of exercise: endurancestrengthflexibility, and balance. The CDC states that physical exercise can reduce the risks of obesity, heart disease, some cancers, type 2 diabetes, high blood pressure, stroke, dementia, depression, and anxiety.  Participating in any exercise, whether it is housework, yardwork, walking or standing up when talking on the phone, is often thought to be better than none when it comes to health.Exercising in nature is even better.

Sleep

Sleep is an essential component to maintaining health. In children, sleep is also vital for growth and development. Ongoing sleep deprivation has been linked to an increased risk for some chronic health problems like-memory issue, mood changes, weakened immunity, weight gain, high blood pressure and stroke.

10- Tzedakah (Righteousness)

You give a poor man a fish and you feed him for a day. You teach him to fish; you feed him for a life time.”

      – Lao Tzu, Chinese Philosopher (6th century BCE)

Tzedakah or Ṣedaqah is a Hebrew word meaning “righteousness”, but commonly used to signify charity. This concept of “charity” differs from the modern Western understanding of “charity.”  Unlike voluntary giving, tzedakah is seen as a religious obligation that must be performed regardless of one’s financial standing, and so is mandatory even for those of limited financial means. 

In the middle Ages, Maimonides conceived of an eight-level hierarchy of tzedakah, where the highest form is to give a gift, loan, or partnership that will result in the recipient becoming self-sufficient instead of living upon others. In his view, the second highest form of tzedakah is to give donations anonymously to unknown recipients.

The Torah (The first five books of Hebrew Bible) requires that 10 percent of a Jew’s income be allotted to righteous deeds or causes, regardless if the receiving party is rich or poor.

In Christian theology, charity (Latin: caritas) is considered one of the seven virtues and is understood by Thomas Aquinas as “the friendship of man for God”, which “unites us to God”. He holds it as “the most excellent of the virtues”.

Dāna in Indian religions

The practice of charity is called Dana or Daana in Hinduism, Buddhism and Jainism. It is the virtue of generosity or giving .The earliest known discussion of charity as a virtuous practice, isin the Rigveda (2nd millennium BCE). According to other ancient texts of Hinduism, Dana can take the form of feeding or giving to an individual in distress or need. It can also take the form of philanthropic public projects that empower and help many.

Zakat and Sadaqah in Islam]

In Islam, there are two methods of charity. One called Zakat, the called Sadaqah.

Zakat is one of the five pillars upon which the Muslim religion is based. It is compulsory for a Muslim to give 2.5% of one’s saving as Zakat, per Islamic calendar year. Sadaqah is voluntary charity or contribution. Sadaqah can be given using money, personal items, time or other resources. There is no minimum or maximum requirement for Sadaqah. Even smiling to other people is considered a Sadaqah.

Conclusion

To lead a reasonably good life, treat others as you like to be treated. It is a commandment advocated by all the major religions. Beware of “Us vs them” ideology. It is the main cause of conflicts and prejudices in all societies. We have all kinds of cognitive biases which lead to bad judgments. Always remember that, there is no such thing as a “free lunch”. Somebody is paying for it. If someone makes you an offer that is “too good to be true”, most likely it is a scam. Don’t fall for it. Know the 80-20 rule and concentrate your efforts on the top 20% of the things you have to do in life. Know that black swan effect like 2000 market crash, 9/11, 100 -year flood, can happen. They have happened before and will happen again. Be prepared, for unexpected events like major accident or even death. Buy appropriate insurance. Failure is not always a bad thing. Just learn from it and move on. The road to financial security is not easy, but can be done: live within your means, start saving early at least 10 percent of your paycheck, maximize your employer’s retirement plan and invest it in an Index fund. The most important of all, take care of your health: maintain an ideal body weight, eat a healthydiet (more towards vegetarian), stay active and get a good night sleep. If possible take a walk in nature.  Remember the meaning of the Hebrew word “Tzedakah”. It is more than charity. Help somebody to stand on his/her feet.

I will conclude this essay with a poem by the American poet Emily Dickinson.

“If I can stop one heart from breaking”

If I can stop one heart from breaking,
I shall not live in vain;
If I can ease one life the aching,
Or cool one pain,
Or help one fainting robin
Unto his nest again,
I shall not live in vain.

By: Emily Dickinson

(Source- Wikipedia.org )

The End

The Best Ways to Lose Weight and Keeping it Off

0

Dr Saheb Sahu, FAAP, MPH.

I want to weigh less, not through diet and exercise, but acquiring a faulty scale. Jarod Kintz

Definitions of Terms

Body Mass Index (BMI) is used by doctors to define, normal, overweight and obesity. A BMI below 18.5 is considered underweight, 18.5-24.9 is normal weight, 25.-29.9 is overweightand 30 or higher is obese.For Asians ,newer studies show that normal BMI is 18.5-23, instead of up to 24.9 (bmisite.net).

 A calorie is the measurement of a unit of energy. I gram of carbohydrate and protein have 4 Calories each and I gram of fat has 9 Calories.

“There is not a doubt that obesity increases risk for a wide range of chronic diseases” says David Ludwig, professor of nutrition at Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health. It has been proven beyond reasonable doubts that obesity increases the risks for high blood pressure, heart disease, stroke, type-2 diabetes, certain cancers, memory failure and arthritis.

A recent review of 121 trials of various diets found that participants’ weight and blood pressure measures generally improved after six months on the diet. But after a year, most people regained the weight and any cardiovascular (heart and vessels) improvements mostly disappeared.

If you want to lose weight, as many people do, calories and exercise remain the two crucial levers.  To lose weight,  you have to eat fewer calories and use more calories than you take in. This can be challenging for most people to do for an extended period of time. “Reducing daily calories intake is the most important factor for weight loss” says Ju .Young Kim, of the Journal of Obesity and Metabolic Syndrome. The key issue is finding a sustainable way to eat healthy, in terms of both quality and quantity. Very few New Year’s resolution diets are sustainable. They can even be counterproductive, by leaving people with impression that progress is possible. Any diet plan to lose weight is unpleasant and short-lived. Will power usually does not work. Simple rules are better.

Added sugar and sweeteners in many of our processed food products is a big problem. They trick our body into wanting even more food. They are the driving force behind the global diabetes and obesity epidemics, which in turn cause many chronic health problems. Beverages are one of the biggest sources of added sugar in our diets. A single 16 –ounce can of Coke has 52 grams of sugar. That is more added sugar than most adults should consume in an entire day. All sweet foods have some kind of sugar- grain sugar, brown sugar, honey, maple syrup or artificial sweetener. Some experts now believe that artificial sweeteners lead to “weight gain and metabolic abnormalities”.

Follow a Healthy Eating Plan

A heathy eating plan includes:

  • Controlling the portion size (most important),
  • A variety of vegetables, fruits and whole grains such as brown rice, whole wheat and oats,
  • Fat-free or low fat dairy products such as milk, yogurt and cheese,
  • A variety of protein foods including legumes (beans and peas), soy products, nuts, seeds, eggs, fish and sea foods, poultry and limited lean meat,
  • Oils such as canola oil, oliveoil and those found in nuts, olives and avocados,
  • Consuming fewer foods and drinks that have refined carbohydrates, added sugars and salt,
  • Limiting foods with saturated fats and trans fats, like those found in desserts and fried foods.

 To learn more about a healthy eating plan visit ChooseMyPlate.gov

Physical Activity for Healthy Weight

Regular physical activity is important for good health. It is especially important to lose weight or to maintain a healthy weight.

When losing weight, more physical activity increases the number of calories your body uses for energy or “burn off”. The burning off calories through physical activity, combining with reducing the number of calories you eat, creates a“caloric deficit” that results in weight loss.

Most importantly, physical activity reduces the risk of high blood pressure, heart attack, stroke, type-2 diabetes, several forms of cancer, arthritis; reduce risk of bone thinning (osteoporosis) and falls.

The benefits of exercise are quite clear on the Brian: Improve memory, increase the capacity to learn (especially children), improve mood and lower anxiety, and to slow aging. Exercise in nature is even more beneficial.

How Much Physical Activity?

 To maintain your weight: Work your way up to 150 minutes of moderate- intensity aerobic activity or 75 minutes of vigorous intensity aerobic activity each week. Moderate intensity activities include- walking, yard work, playing with children or biking at causal pace. Vigorous activities (your heart rate increases substantially) include: Running, swimming laps, jumping ropes and competitive sports.

Conclusion

There is no mystery about how to eat better. You do not have to worry about the fine points of the latest scientific research. The overall picture has been remarkably quite consistent for years. A healthy diet revolves around mostly unprocessed foods, like vegetables, fruits, nuts, beans, whole grain, fish and some meat. The famous food writer Michel Pollan’s seven word manifesto still holds: “Eat Food. Not too much.  Mostly plants”.

 To lose weight and to maintain it, you must also exercise. You have to burn more calories than you take. Be safe- start slowly and talk to your doctor if you have health problem or an injury. Choose activity you enjoy and try new ones, but keep moving. Being more active will help you manage your weight besides all the other benefits mentioned earlier.

Bottom line- if you are not losing at least one kilogram or more (2-3 pounds) a month, than you are still eating too much!

Sources

1-CDC.gov/healthy weight. 2-Dietaryguidelines.gov. 3- MyPlate.gov.

4- David Leonhardt. The Morning: A food audit. The New York Times, January7, 2022

How Dharmendra Can Become CM?

0

Dharmendra Pradhan the BJP’s CM face for Odisha trying hard to install BJP in Odisha since 2016.  He makes the necessary changes in the organisational set up and made Basanta Panda the President of BJP Odisha in 2016.  He used all his forces to downsize his competitor in the party like Jual Oram and KV Singhdeo etc. BJP send many Union ministers many a time including their master election strategist Amit Shah. BJP’s slogan to dislodge BJD was “19 years of incapable and incompetent Naveen Sarkar”. But BJP got only 23 MLAs in 2019 election.

Within the end of one month of the election BJD voted BJP Rajy Sabha MP Ashwin Vaishnaw from Odisha. It was a clear compromise between both the parties that BJP will not harsh BJD with CBI, ED etc and BJD will support them in Rajy Sabha as well as in Lok Sabha. Now with this compromising political scenario no doubt both parties can get temporary benefits but BJP and Dharmendra cannot succeed to the throne.

BJP sources says that BJD will be weaker after Naveen Patnaik and party may collapse but I think they have little idea that his nephew Arun Patnaik will succeed him and at that time the political scenario will be very different from now. At that time Naveen babu will be an even larger poster figure than his father Biju babu. And there will be difficulties for BJP to capture Bhubneswar.

But BJP have few options. They may keep continue their aggressive campaigning like before the election time detaching all political tie up from BJD or either bifurcating the state into Utkal & Kosal region.

BJP need to understand that Odisha is not a cow belt. Ideas like Baba, Gomata, Ganga Mata etc will not work here. Odisha is affluent with adivasis with two major cultural regions; Utkal & Kosal. If Kosal is bifurcated out of Odisha then Kosal part will be leaderless for BJD. Definitely Naveen babu’s charisma will limited to Utkal region. And BJP may continue the power for a longer time in Kosal without any political thereat.

Saket Sreebhushan Sahu       

Guide to Your Baby’s First Year

0

Dr Saheb Sahu, FAAP, MPH.

I am a pediatrician. I just read a book by Alice Callahan, PHD, titled “The Science of Mom, A Research-Based Guide to Your Baby’s First Year (2021). Callahan does the work of sorting through the science of baby’s first year, so you don’t have to. Here are the some of the main points of the book.

1- Vaccinations

Give the baby all the vaccinations recommended by American Academy of Pediatrics, or Center of Disease Control (CDC) or WHO (World Health Organization). Vaccinations which are given during the first year are: Hepatitis B, Rotavirus (to prevent diarrhea), DTP (Diphtheria, Tetanus and Pertussis), Hemophilus influenza type b (Hib), Pneumococcal conjugate (Pcv-13), Inactivated polio and Influenza. Most of these vaccines are given at 2, 4, and 6 months of age and the booster dose at 9-15 months. (Source-Immunization page, Cdc.gov/vaccine).

2- Sleeping

SIDS- Sudden Infant Death Syndrome occurs in babies less than 12 months of age, but most death happen between 2 and 4 months, and 90 percent occur before 6 months of age.

 Safe sleep recommendations:

  •  Always put your baby down for sleep on his/her back and on a firm and flat mattress.
  • The safest place for your baby to sleep is in a crib or bassinet in your room.
  • Avoid sleeping with your baby in a couch or chair.
  • Don’t over bundle the baby; dress her just enough to stay warm.

3- Breast Feeding

Breast feeding is good for babies and mothers and science backs substantial benefits. Unfortunately, just about 44 percent of infants worldwide are exclusively breast fed until 5 months (UNICEF-2019). Most health organizations now recommend exclusive breastfeeding for first six months of a baby’s life.

 Breast milk is packed with hormones, growth factors, and stem cells, as well as immunoglobulins to ward off pathogens. Breastfed babies have lower incidence of gastrointestinal, respiratory, and ear infections. A 2015 meta-analysis of 17 studies found that breastfeeding was associated with an increase in 3.4 IQ points.

Breast milk contains very little Vitamin D. Exclusively breastfed infants should receive a daily dose of 400 international units of supplemental vitamin D, which is important for bone growth. Iron supplements is also recommended for exclusively breastfed babies around 4 months and continue until they start eating iron –rich solid foods.

 Studies consistently find that breastfeeding, especially for longer durations, is associated with a reduced risk of breast and ovarian cancer for the mother, as well as lower risk of high blood pressure (11% lower) and type-2 diabetes (30 % lower) later in life.

4- Starting Solid Foods

WHO recommends that all babies be exclusively breastfed—meaning no formula or solid food—for the first 6 months of life. Many other health organizations, recommend starting solid between 4 and 6 months of age.

 Choking on solid foods can be a life threatening problem. Take the following steps to prevent choking and be sure you’re prepared to respond:

  • Your baby should be sitting upright and always supervised during feeding. Test foods before they are offered to ensure they are soft.
  • Avoid foods with choking hazards: nuts and seeds, hot dogs, chunk of meat or cheese, whole grapes, hard candy or gum, popcorn, globs of peanut butter, and other round firm foods (raw fruits and vegetables).
  • Know the Heimlich maneuver and CPR (cardio pulmonary resuscitation) for babies, children and adults. (www.heart.org, American Heart Association online course).

 One of the goals of complimentary feeding is to introduce your baby to a variety of foods from all food groups. Benefits of dietary diversity in infancy include balanced nutritional intake and reduce risk of developing food allergy.

 There is little difference in the nutritional profile of organic and conventional milk and meat and both are safe for the baby. Make your own baby foods. Baby foods marketed by big companies often have added sugar, salt and filler ingredients. These meals are expensive and nutrient-poor and they don’t help your baby learn to eat real food. Check labels carefully.

Offer nutrient dense foods to meet nutrient needs like meat, fish, eggs, dairy products, vegetables and fruits. Introduce a variety of food. Let your baby explore many tastes and textures.

 Source

Alice Callahan, PHD. The Science of Mom, A Research-Based Guide to Your Baby’s First Year. 2nd Ed. John Hopkins University Press, Baltimore,2021